The Retirement Decision Lab

Decision 4 · Week 4 · Wed Dec 2

How do couples decide on retirement when they disagree?

SHORT ANSWERSeparate the facts from the preferences, run each person's version of retirement with the same numbers, plan the gap between two retirement dates, and test what happens to the survivor. Most disagreements shrink once both plans are priced.

Disagreement is normal, and so is retiring at different times. In a 2024 Ameriprise study of 1,510 couples, 26% of pre-retirees planned to retire at the same time, but only 11% of retired couples actually did, and 62% retired at least a year apart [1]. A Fidelity survey cited by the Center for Retirement Research found only 43% of people correctly knew when their partner planned to retire [2].

Most fights mix facts and preferences. Facts are balances, benefit estimates, pension terms and health costs. Preferences are when, where and how you want to live. Agree on the facts first, in one shared sheet, then talk about preferences with real prices attached.

Partners also weigh money differently. Research cited by the Center for Retirement Research found that men, far more than women, were influenced by their wives' financial prospects from working [2].

Plan for the survivor. For Social Security, a surviving spouse at full retirement age can get up to 100% of the deceased spouse's benefit, but the two benefits are not added together [3]. For a married couple at 65, the odds are at least even that one of you lives past 90 [4].

What a split-the-difference compromise misses: the right answer for timing and the right answer for the survivor can point different ways. Price both before you trade.

Planned versus actual retirement timing for couples, Ameriprise 2024
GroupRetire at the same timeRetire apart
Couples not yet retired (plans)26% [1]39% expect more than a year apart [1]
Retired couples (what happened)11% [1]62% at least a year apart [1]
Illustrative example

Illustrative example: stopping at 62 versus 66

  • Partner A wants to stop at 62. Partner B wants A to work until 66.
  • Gap: 4 years
  • Pay A gives up at $50,000 a year: 4 x $50,000 = $200,000 before tax
  • Health coverage for A from 62 to Medicare at 65, at $700 a month: 36 x $700 = $25,200
  • Cost of stopping at 62 instead of 66: $200,000 + $25,200 = $225,200
  • Per year of the gap: $225,200 / 4 = $56,300

Hypothetical numbers. Leaves out taxes, Social Security changes and investment returns. The point is to argue about a number, not a feeling.

Illustrative only, not a prediction or a recommendation. Your own figures will differ.

How to decide

  1. Each partner writes down, alone, when they want to stop, where they want to live, and why.
  2. Build one shared sheet of facts: balances, Social Security estimates, pensions, debts and health costs.
  3. Price partner A's plan and partner B's plan with the same returns, inflation and spending.
  4. Put a dollar figure on the years between the two retirement dates.
  5. Test both survivor cases: what the household has if either partner dies first [3].
  6. Trade on the priced gap. Write down what you agreed and the date you will revisit it.

When this may not apply

  • If one partner has serious health problems, the survivor case may matter more than the timing.
  • If one of you has a pension with a survivor option, that choice is often hard or impossible to change later. Decide it together before signing.
  • If the disagreement is about more than money, a counselor or mediator may help more than a spreadsheet.

Where it gets personal In Week 4 each partner's version is run side by side with the same numbers, including both survivor cases.

Sources

  1. American Couples Have Shared Goals for Retirement, but Haven't Nailed Down the Details: New Research from Ameriprise Financial · Ameriprise Financial
  2. Why Couples Retire Together, or Don't · Center for Retirement Research at Boston College
  3. What you could get from Survivor benefits · Social Security Administration
  4. When to Start Receiving Retirement Benefits (EN-05-10147) · Social Security Administration

Written and reviewed by Todd Allyn, Founding Director, Sovereo Intelligence: 24 years teaching economics, finance and business, former business school dean, not a financial advisor.
Updated · Facts checked · Next review by
How we source answers · Report an error

Did this answer your question?
Cohort 01 · Enrollment opens Oct 11

Apply this answer to your own numbers.

The Retirement Decision Lab works through what your retirement will look like and the rest of your retirement decisions in four live 90-minute sessions, on your real income and costs, ending with your personal Retirement Decision Brief.

$297 once · Wednesdays, 7pm Eastern · Nov 4, 11, 18 and Dec 2 · Enrollment Oct 11 to Oct 23, noon ET

Waitlist members hear first. We only email you about the Lab. How the Lab works

Ask the Lab

Still have a question?

Ask it in your own words. If we haven't answered it yet, we will.