The Retirement Decision Lab

Decision 3 · Week 3 · Wed Nov 18

Should I downsize my home in retirement?

SHORT ANSWERIt depends on four numbers: the equity you free up, what the sale and move cost, the tax on any gain (up to $500,000 can be excluded on a joint return if you meet the 2-of-5-year test), and how much lower your carrying costs will be.

Start with what you free up. Example, with made-up numbers: you sell for $450,000 and buy a smaller place for $300,000. That frees $150,000 before costs. Subtract agent fees, closing costs, repairs to sell, and moving. Those can eat a large share of the difference, so price them in your own market.

Next, tax. If you owned and lived in the home for at least 2 of the last 5 years, you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain, or $500,000 on a joint return [1]. You generally lose the exclusion if you used it on another home sale in the prior 2 years [1]. A gain above the limit is taxable and is reported on Schedule D and Form 8949 [1].

Then compare yearly carrying costs: property tax, insurance, utilities, maintenance, HOA dues, and any mortgage. Housing is the biggest line for most households: 33.4% of average US household spending in 2024, according to BLS [3]. In 2023, 43% of older homeowners with a mortgage spent more than 30% of income on housing, versus 19% of those who owned free and clear, according to Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies [2].

Finally, the parts that are not money: stairs, distance to family and doctors, and whether the new place works if your health changes.

What the rule of thumb misses: a smaller home is not always cheaper. A condo with high HOA dues, or a move to a pricier area, can raise carrying costs even after a lower price.

Home sale gain you may exclude from tax
SituationGain you can exclude
Single, owned and lived there 2 of the last 5 yearsUp to $250,000 [1]
Married filing jointly, both lived there 2 of the last 5 yearsUp to $500,000 [1]
Used the exclusion on another home sold in the last 2 yearsGenerally none [1]
Illustrative example

Illustrative example: selling a $450,000 home

  • Sale price: $450,000
  • Selling and moving costs, assumed at 8%: $450,000 x 0.08 = $36,000
  • Next home: $300,000 plus $6,000 in buying costs = $306,000
  • Equity freed: $450,000 minus $36,000 minus $306,000 = $108,000
  • Yearly carrying costs: $14,000 now versus $9,500 after, a saving of $4,500 a year
  • If you paid $200,000 for the home, the gain is about $250,000 before selling costs, under the $500,000 joint limit

Hypothetical numbers. The 8% cost and the carrying costs are assumptions, not source figures. Price them in your own market.

Illustrative only, not a prediction or a recommendation. Your own figures will differ.

How to decide

  1. Start with your likely sale price. Subtract agent fees, closing costs, repairs and moving.
  2. Subtract the price of the next home and its buying costs. What is left is the equity you free up.
  3. Check the tax. Gain up to $250,000, or $500,000 on a joint return, is excluded if you meet the 2-of-5-year test [1].
  4. List yearly carrying costs for both homes side by side: tax, insurance, utilities, upkeep, HOA dues and mortgage.
  5. Add the freed equity to your savings and the yearly savings to your budget. Then rerun how long your money lasts.
  6. Test the parts that are not money: stairs, doctors, family, and whether you could stay if your health changed.

When this may not apply

  • If you rented out the home or used part of it for business, your exclusion may be smaller. IRS Publication 523 has the details [1].
  • If you do not meet the 2-year test, you may still qualify for a partial exclusion in some cases. IRS Publication 523 explains when [1].
  • If you are moving abroad, a US citizen still owes US tax, and the new country may tax the sale too. Get tax advice first.
  • If the smaller home has high HOA dues or is in a pricier area, carrying costs may not fall.

Where it gets personal In Week 3 you run your own sale, purchase, and yearly costs side by side to see what downsizing actually frees up.

Sources

  1. Topic no. 701, Sale of your home · Internal Revenue Service
  2. One in Three Older Households Is Cost Burdened · Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies
  3. Consumer Expenditures, 2024 · U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics

Written and reviewed by Todd Allyn, Founding Director, Sovereo Intelligence: 24 years teaching economics, finance and business, former business school dean, not a financial advisor.
Updated · Facts checked · Next review by
How we source answers · Report an error

Did this answer your question?
Cohort 01 · Enrollment opens Oct 11

Apply this answer to your own numbers.

The Retirement Decision Lab works through where your money works hardest and the rest of your retirement decisions in four live 90-minute sessions, on your real income and costs, ending with your personal Retirement Decision Brief.

$297 once · Wednesdays, 7pm Eastern · Nov 4, 11, 18 and Dec 2 · Enrollment Oct 11 to Oct 23, noon ET

Waitlist members hear first. We only email you about the Lab. How the Lab works

Ask the Lab

Still have a question?

Ask it in your own words. If we haven't answered it yet, we will.