The Retirement Decision Lab

Decision 3 · Week 3 · Wed Nov 18

Is it better to rent or own in retirement?

SHORT ANSWERNeither is better in general. Owning gives stable costs if the home is paid off but ties up equity and leaves you with taxes, insurance, and repairs. Renting gives flexibility and frees equity, but rent can rise every year.

Owning outright removes the biggest housing bill, but not all of them. Property tax, insurance, utilities, and maintenance keep coming, and insurance has been rising. Renting moves repairs and property tax to the landlord, but you have no control over rent increases.

The data show the difference in risk. In 2023, 58% of renters 65 and older paid more than 30% of income for housing. For older homeowners it was nearly 28%, and 19% for those with no mortgage, per Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies.

The case for renting is usually about the equity. Example with made-up numbers: you own a $400,000 home free and clear. Sell it and, if the money earned 4% a year, it would produce about $16,000 a year, or $1,333 a month, toward rent. Compare that, plus the owning costs you no longer pay, with the rent for a place you would want. Married couples filing jointly can exclude up to $500,000 of gain on the sale ($250,000 for single filers) if they meet the 2-of-5-years test.

Then weigh what money does not capture: owning protects you from being asked to move, while renting makes it easier to move closer to family or care later. Selling also means you no longer gain if home prices rise, or lose if they fall.

What the rule of thumb misses: the choice is not permanent, but switching is expensive. Selling and buying back in later costs fees each time.

Where it gets personal In Week 3 you run your own home's equity, owning costs, and local rents through the comparison.

Sources

  1. One in Three Older Households Is Cost Burdened · Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies
  2. Topic no. 701, Sale of your home · Internal Revenue Service

Written and reviewed by Todd Allyn, Founding Director, Sovereo Intelligence: 24 years teaching economics, finance and business, former business school dean, not a financial advisor.
Facts checked · Next review by
How we source answers · Report an error

Did this answer your question?
Cohort 01 · Enrollment opens Oct 11

Apply this answer to your own numbers.

The Retirement Decision Lab works through where your money works hardest and the rest of your retirement decisions in four live 90-minute sessions, on your real income and costs, ending with your personal Retirement Decision Brief.

$297 once · Wednesdays, 7pm Eastern · Nov 4, 11, 18 and Dec 2 · Enrollment Oct 11 to Oct 23, noon ET

Waitlist members hear first. We only email you about the Lab. How the Lab works

Ask the Lab

Still have a question?

Ask it in your own words. If we haven't answered it yet, we will.